Esteban Torres reviewed Translation State by Ann Leckie (Imperial Radch)
Ok-ish
3 stars
2.8 stars for me. I feel like the lore and complexity of the characters would have fit better a saga. Compressed into a single file book made it not work great
422 pages
English language
Published Oct. 12, 2023
Qven was created to be a Presger translator. The pride of their Clade, they always had a clear path before them: learn human ways, and eventually, make a match and serve as an intermediary between the dangerous alien Presger and the human worlds. The realization that they might want something else isn't "optimal behavior". I's the type of behavior that results in elimination.
But Qven rebels. And in doing so, their path collides with those of two others. Enae, a reluctant diplomat whose dead grandmaman has left hir an impossible task as an inheritance: hunting down a fugitive who has been missing for over 200 years. And Reet, an adopted mechanic who is increasingly desperate to learn about his genetic roots—or anything that might explain why he operates so differently from those around him.
As a Conclave of the various species approaches—and the long-standing treaty between the humans and the …
Qven was created to be a Presger translator. The pride of their Clade, they always had a clear path before them: learn human ways, and eventually, make a match and serve as an intermediary between the dangerous alien Presger and the human worlds. The realization that they might want something else isn't "optimal behavior". I's the type of behavior that results in elimination.
But Qven rebels. And in doing so, their path collides with those of two others. Enae, a reluctant diplomat whose dead grandmaman has left hir an impossible task as an inheritance: hunting down a fugitive who has been missing for over 200 years. And Reet, an adopted mechanic who is increasingly desperate to learn about his genetic roots—or anything that might explain why he operates so differently from those around him.
As a Conclave of the various species approaches—and the long-standing treaty between the humans and the Presger is on the line—the decisions of all three will have ripple effects across the stars.
Masterfully merging space adventure and mystery, and a poignant exploration about relationships and belonging, Translation State is a triumphant new standalone story set in the celebrated Imperial Radch universe.
2.8 stars for me. I feel like the lore and complexity of the characters would have fit better a saga. Compressed into a single file book made it not work great
I hadn't heard that this one was coming until it appeared, and it was a delightful surprise. To my mind Leckie is the greatest produce of space opera since Iain M. Banks. In some ways this book was the most like a Culture novel to date, but it's an injustice to discuss her work just by comparison.
The story, which cycles through three points of view, wrestles with the slippery, dynamic notions of boundaries, relationships, and identities. These three things are part and parcel of one another - you cannot have one without the others. We cannot systematise these things, but only live through them and work at them, rather than fix and determine them for good. The whole story is a process of grappling with that fact.
Most of the characters are pleasant and sympathetic. This is refreshing in a field which, to this reader at least, so often …
I hadn't heard that this one was coming until it appeared, and it was a delightful surprise. To my mind Leckie is the greatest produce of space opera since Iain M. Banks. In some ways this book was the most like a Culture novel to date, but it's an injustice to discuss her work just by comparison.
The story, which cycles through three points of view, wrestles with the slippery, dynamic notions of boundaries, relationships, and identities. These three things are part and parcel of one another - you cannot have one without the others. We cannot systematise these things, but only live through them and work at them, rather than fix and determine them for good. The whole story is a process of grappling with that fact.
Most of the characters are pleasant and sympathetic. This is refreshing in a field which, to this reader at least, so often makes a virtue of cynicism. That's not to say they don't have their flaws, nor are they entirely unproblematic, but they are not out to wow you with how gritty and uncompromisingly grim they are.
Leckie is brilliant.
What a lovely tale of identity, family, acceptance, and binge-watching Pirate Exiles under a blanket fort.
This follows the Imperial Radch Trilogy much more directly than Provenance did - I would definitely read those books first. But do. And then read this one.
It feels like there must have been piles more POV characters in this book than the others but now trying to remember after the fact there were only three? Regardless, I sometimes had trouble tracking what was happening and integrating events into the core thread of the story.
Whereas I tend to classify the Ancillary trio as stories about consent that use gender and identity as world-building color, much of Translation State struck me as the inverse— a story fundamentally about identity where lack of consent is used to highlight or intensify the characters’ struggles to know themselves. The denouement however ties everything together: /informed/ consent, or gtfo.
Bonus brain-bending geometry puzzles and backstory for some of the weirder moments from translators in previous books.
CN for squick-inducing body horror (experienced by someone not expecting it), non-squick-inducing body horror (experienced by someone for whom it is normal), and neutral/normalized gore …
It feels like there must have been piles more POV characters in this book than the others but now trying to remember after the fact there were only three? Regardless, I sometimes had trouble tracking what was happening and integrating events into the core thread of the story.
Whereas I tend to classify the Ancillary trio as stories about consent that use gender and identity as world-building color, much of Translation State struck me as the inverse— a story fundamentally about identity where lack of consent is used to highlight or intensify the characters’ struggles to know themselves. The denouement however ties everything together: /informed/ consent, or gtfo.
Bonus brain-bending geometry puzzles and backstory for some of the weirder moments from translators in previous books.
CN for squick-inducing body horror (experienced by someone not expecting it), non-squick-inducing body horror (experienced by someone for whom it is normal), and neutral/normalized gore and violence. Brief analogue to sexual assault, sustained analogue to SA-induced PTSD.
Really dug this. Continues Leckie's exploration of gender and identity. Likewise attends to some interesting caregiving dynamics. I think the title nicely signals all of this: the work of transitioning across gender and identity and also phases of life. Plus, weird alien doors.
Finally we get to learn more about the mysterious Presger. A really enjoyable ride through one of my favourite universes